Thanks FollowedOn
Ability feedback from CC23 is largely irrelevant as abilities are dynamic. I'm working on some anomalies I've spotted with SA players in CC24. Rabada has always been highly rated, so not sure what the issue is there.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
South Africa 20 Over Squads
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
Rassie opens in T20
Delano Potgieter looks a bit overrated in terms of salary, also needs to be slightly more of a batting all rounder than what he currently is
George Linde underrated, should be in the team
Rabada still looks underrated based on his salary
Junior Dala looks underrated, had a good SA20
Maharaj looks underrated
Hermann should be selected over Erwee
Patrick Kruger bats at 6 and should get a boost, he played for South Africa
Baartman looks underrated
Marco Jansen should be an all-rounder
Simon Harmer was overrated in the last game, not sure if he's been nerfed, but he shouldn't be making SA sides unless as second spinner
Makhanya looks a bit underrated
Gerald Coetzee looks underrated
Lhuan-dre Pretorius should be aggressive, was very attacking in the U19 world cup
Maphaka should be LF and needs to have very high potential
Ngidi and Fortuin should be in the Paarl XI
Pretoria are missing Steve Stolk
I also hope the regens have been rebalanced, they take over the domestic and international sides after 2-3 years which isn't realistic at all
And then all the same changes I recommended in the database feedback thread:
For South Africa:
Batsmen:
Markram - Doesn't open in ODIs, bats 4. Needs a boost with his bowling (Bavuma bowls ahead of him as 6th choice)
Ryan Rickleton - Could still be a better bat, especially in OD/T20 cricket. Also bats 4 in FC
Janneman Malan - Overrated, shouldn't be in the South African team. Has had 2 years of terrible form.
Joshua Richards - Overrated, shouldn't be in the test team, isn't close to it really.
Tony De Zorzi - Underrated, is playing in tests and ODI team. Will open the batting now Elgar is retired so keep him as an opener.
Riley Rossouw - Overrated, shouldn't be in the South African team, especially in ODI (I think he's retired from OD cricket anyway)
Dewald Brevis - Needs a slight boost with the bat and ball. Higher potential as well
David Bedingham - Seriously underrated. Looks like arguably our best red ball batsmen and should be locked into the test side.
Rassie vd Dussent - Bit overrated, isn't making test/T20 sides anytime soon.
Temba Bavuma - Opens in OD cricket, maybe a bit overrated?
Connor Esterhuizen - Very underrated with the bat. Played for MI Cape Town and is getting into a very strong Lions side domestically
Jason Smith - More of a batsmen these days and could use an upgrade
Rubin Hermann - Could get a slight upgrade in batting
Rivaldo Moonsamy - Opens in T20 cricket and could use an upgrade in his batting
Sibonelo Makhanya - Needs an upgrade in his batting
Gavin Kaplan - Bats 4 in FC and needs an upgrade in his batting
Jean du Plessis - Big upgrade in batting,
Ronan Hermann - Needs a boost, already signed for SA20
All-Rounders:
Wiaan Mulder - Immensely overrated with bat and ball, within a year he's batting 4 in all formats for South Africa. He should be in the fringes with decent potential
Donovan Ferreira - Underrated with bat and ball, bowling he's arguably an all-rounder domestically and batting needs a boost, should be in the SA T20 team after Miller and Klaasen are gone
Evan Jones - Bit overrated with the bat and underrated with the ball, makes SA teams (does a bit too well with the bat) but doesn't bowl, he's a pure all-rounder
Ruan de Swardt - Bit underrated with the ball.
Delano Potgieter - Very underrated with the bat and slightly overrated with the ball. He's a batting all-rounder.
Marco Jansen - Should be an all-rounder. Bats 7 for South Africa.
Beyers Swanepoel - Underrated with the ball. Should be breaking into SA sides.
Eathan Bosch - Overrated, not near the SA squad
Neil Brand - Opens in FC cricket, could get a boost in batting.
Thomas Kaber - Underrated with the ball, did decently in the SA20
Bryce Parsons - Bats 4 in FC cricket and could used an upgrade in batting
Kyle Simmonds - Could use an upgrade in his bowling
Mihlali Mpongwana - Should be an all-rounder and needs boost in batting and bowling
Jason Niemand - Should be an all-rounder and could get an upgrade in his batting
Bowlers:
Imraan Manack - Upgrade in bowling, very good defensive T20 spinner
Nqaba Peter- Upgrade in bowling, highly rated leg spinner
Junior Dala - Upgrade in bowling
Tabraiz Shamsi - Could do with an upgrade in bowling
Migael Pretorius - Upgrade in batting (yes batting)
Codi Yusuf - Should be a bowler and underrated with ball.
Matthew Boast - Needs a big boost with the ball and is not an all-rounder. One of SA's better bowling talents
Simon Harmer - Extremely overrated, shouldn't be playing for South Africa except as a back up spinner for tests
Duanne Olivier - Overrated, shouldn't be in the test team.
Rabada - Somehow underrated? Gets dropped from the test side early, should be retiring as an AT great.
Nandre Burger - Extremely underrated, should be in the SA side.
Kwena Maphaka - Extremely underrated, should be LF and close to SA side.
Ottniel Baartman - Needs a boost in bowling
Siya Plaatjie - Is a bowler
Gerald Coetzee - Needs a boost in bowlingLast edited by Sureshot; 06-02-2024, 02:37 PM.
Leave a comment:
-
South Africa 20 Over Squads
Reminder our bowling speed is RM> RFM > RMF > RF
I've not yet added players who haven't played any professional match.
Any issues, please be as clear as possible.
Please note you may see differences between players on these screenshots and from other screenshots as there have been changes since.
Cape Town
Durban
Eastern Cape
Johannesburg
Paarl
Pretoria
Tags: None
Leave a comment: